What is voluntary submission to liability?
Voluntary submission to liability is a special consensual procedure available in Polish fiscal criminal law under the Fiscal Penal Code (Kodeks karny skarbowy, k.k.s.). It may be used in cases concerning fiscal offences and fiscal misdemeanours, including certain tax, customs, excise and foreign-exchange infringements.
The procedure allows the perpetrator to accept financial liability without undergoing a full criminal trial. In practice, the person concerned applies for permission to submit voluntarily to liability, pays the required public-law dues, an amount corresponding to a fine and procedural costs, and the court decides whether to approve the arrangement.
Voluntary submission to liability is not automatic. It requires the fulfilment of statutory conditions and the support of the competent financial authority. The court retains the final decision on whether permission should be granted. The procedure is intended for cases in which the circumstances of the act and the offender’s guilt do not raise significant doubts.
How does voluntary submission to liability work?
The procedure usually begins during preparatory proceedings conducted by a financial authority, such as the head of a tax office or customs and tax office. The person suspected of committing a fiscal offence or fiscal misdemeanour may request permission to submit voluntarily to liability.
Before the application can be considered, the person must generally settle the due public-law receivable that was diminished by the offence, if such a receivable exists. This may include unpaid tax, customs duty, excise duty or another payment due to the State Treasury or a local government unit.
The applicant must also pay an amount corresponding to a fine and at least a lump-sum equivalent of the costs of the proceedings. Under Article 17 of the Fiscal Penal Code, the amount paid in place of a fine cannot be lower than one-third of the minimum wage in the case of a fiscal offence and one-tenth of the minimum wage in the case of a fiscal misdemeanour. The applicable amount depends on the legal classification of the act and the circumstances of the case.
If the financial authority supports the application, it submits a request to the court. The court may issue a judgment permitting voluntary submission to liability. Such a judgment may also include measures relating to items connected with the offence, including forfeiture where the statutory conditions are met.
When may voluntary submission to liability be unavailable?
This procedure is not available in every fiscal criminal case. It cannot be used where the relevant offence is punishable by restriction of liberty or imprisonment. It is also excluded in cases involving statutory grounds for extraordinary aggravation of punishment.
Restrictions also apply where a fiscal offence was committed within an organised criminal group or association, or where the person directed such a group or association. The procedure is also unavailable where a person induced another person to commit a fiscal offence in order to have proceedings for that act directed against that other person. The exact assessment depends on the allegations, the evidence collected and the provisions applicable to the particular case.
Importantly, voluntary submission to liability should not be treated as a universal method of closing a dispute with tax or customs authorities. It does not replace an analysis of whether an offence was committed, whether the amount claimed by the authority is correct, or whether another procedural solution would be more appropriate.
When is legal advice useful?
Legal assistance may be particularly important when a taxpayer, company officer, accountant or other person receives a summons, is questioned by a financial authority, or learns that fiscal criminal proceedings have been initiated. A prompt assessment can help determine whether voluntary submission to liability is legally available and financially justified.
A lawyer can examine the proposed legal classification, calculate the amounts that may need to be paid, assess the consequences of accepting liability and verify whether the authority has correctly established the facts. This is especially relevant in matters involving VAT settlements, excise duty, customs declarations, invoices, bookkeeping irregularities, tax returns or cross-border transactions.
Early legal consultation may help avoid procedural mistakes, incomplete submissions, unnecessary financial costs and decisions made without a full understanding of their consequences. It may also be necessary to consider alternatives, including defence against the allegations, correction of tax settlements or the use of other institutions available under fiscal criminal law.
Legal support in fiscal criminal matters may include:
- assessing whether voluntary submission to liability is available in a specific case;
- representing a client before tax, customs and fiscal criminal authorities;
- analysing allegations concerning fiscal offences and fiscal misdemeanours;
- reviewing tax, customs and accounting documentation;
- preparing applications, explanations and procedural submissions;
- assessing the financial and legal consequences of a proposed settlement;
- representing a client in proceedings before a court.
Need legal assistance in a fiscal criminal case? Contact us.