What is a breach of professional secrecy?
A breach of professional secrecy occurs when a person who is legally or professionally required to keep information confidential discloses, uses or makes that information available to an unauthorised person. Professional secrecy protects information obtained in connection with the performance of a profession, public function or professional service.
The obligation may apply, among others, to advocates, attorneys-at-law, legal advisers, doctors, psychologists, notaries, tax advisers, auditors, accountants, financial institutions and employees who have access to confidential business information. The precise scope of confidentiality depends on the profession, the applicable legislation, professional rules and the circumstances in which the information was obtained.
A breach does not always require public disclosure. It may also result from sending documents to the wrong recipient, discussing a client’s case with an unauthorised person, leaving files unsecured, sharing login credentials or using confidential information for personal benefit. In some cases, negligent handling of information may be sufficient to create legal, disciplinary or civil consequences.
What information is covered by professional secrecy?
Professional secrecy may cover facts communicated directly by a client, documents provided during a consultation, correspondence, personal data, financial information, business plans, medical records, information obtained during internal investigations and details learned through the provision of professional services.
In legal practice, confidentiality generally protects information obtained by a lawyer in connection with providing legal assistance. This protection is important because a client must be able to explain the relevant facts openly when seeking legal advice or preparing a defence. Depending on the profession and the legal basis of the duty, the obligation may continue after the professional relationship ends.
The rules are not identical for every profession. Some confidentiality duties arise directly from statutes, while others are based on professional ethical codes, employment contracts, non-disclosure agreements or data protection rules. Certain laws may also provide limited exceptions, for example where disclosure is required by a court, another authorised authority or a specific statutory provision. Whether an exception applies must be assessed carefully in the individual case.
What can constitute a breach of professional secrecy?
A breach of professional secrecy can take many forms. It may involve an intentional disclosure of information, but it can also result from inadequate organisational or technical safeguards. Typical examples include:
- providing confidential documents to an unauthorised third party;
- discussing a client’s case in a place where others can hear the conversation;
- disclosing confidential information in emails, social media posts or public statements;
- using information acquired in a professional capacity for private or commercial purposes;
- losing an unprotected device containing confidential files;
- failing to secure physical records, electronic archives or access credentials;
- giving testimony or explanations without properly assessing the scope of a confidentiality obligation.
Not every disclosure automatically constitutes an unlawful breach. The assessment may depend on whether the person was bound by secrecy, whether the information was confidential, whether the recipient was authorised, whether valid consent was given and whether a statutory exemption applied. The legal analysis may also differ where the information is protected by professional secrecy, business secrecy, attorney-client confidentiality or personal data protection rules.
What are the consequences of breaching professional secrecy?
The consequences may include professional disciplinary proceedings, civil liability for damage, termination of employment or contractual cooperation, reputational harm and, in certain circumstances, criminal liability. A person or entity affected by disclosure may seek compensation if it can demonstrate damage and the legal prerequisites for liability are met.
For businesses, a breach may expose trade secrets, negotiation strategies, internal reports, customer information or financial data. For private individuals, it may lead to the disclosure of sensitive personal, family, health or legal information. Where personal data are involved, the incident may also require an assessment under data protection law, including whether notification duties apply.
When is legal assistance advisable?
Legal advice may be necessary when a professional has received a request to disclose information, has been summoned to give evidence, suspects that confidential materials have been accessed or shared, or is facing disciplinary, civil or criminal allegations. Assistance may also be needed by a client whose confidential information has been disclosed without authorisation.
Businesses should seek advice when an employee, contractor or external service provider may have disclosed confidential information. A prompt assessment can help secure evidence, limit further access, identify reporting obligations and determine whether contractual, civil, disciplinary or criminal measures are justified.
Early consultation can help avoid incorrect disclosures, procedural errors, disputes, financial loss and potential liability. It is particularly important to assess confidentiality before responding to authorities, counterparties, journalists, employees or other third parties.
Legal support in matters concerning professional secrecy
Legal assistance in cases involving a breach of professional secrecy may include:
- assessing the scope of a confidentiality obligation;
- reviewing whether a statutory or contractual exception applies;
- advising on requests for documents, testimony or information;
- representing clients in criminal, disciplinary and civil proceedings;
- preparing notifications, explanations and legal positions;
- assessing claims for compensation and available protective measures;
- reviewing internal confidentiality procedures and document security practices.
Need assistance with a suspected breach of professional secrecy? Contact us.