What is bid rigging?
Bid rigging is a form of unlawful coordination between businesses participating in a tender, auction, request for proposals or other competitive procurement procedure. It occurs when bidders do not prepare their offers independently but agree in advance on the outcome of the procedure, the prices to be submitted, the division of contracts or the identity of the winning bidder.
The purpose of bid rigging is usually to create only an appearance of competition. The organiser – whether a public institution, a state-owned entity or a private company – may believe that it is comparing independent offers. In reality, the bidders may have coordinated their conduct in a way that limits genuine competition and can lead to higher prices, less favourable contractual terms or lower quality of goods and services.
Bid rigging may breach both competition law and criminal law. In Poland, arrangements that restrict competition may be assessed under the Act on Competition and Consumer Protection, while conduct affecting the fairness of a tender or procurement procedure may also give rise to criminal liability under the Polish Criminal Code. The legal assessment depends on the facts of the case, including the type of procedure, the parties involved, the purpose of the arrangement and its impact on competition.
What conduct may constitute bid rigging?
Bid rigging can take different forms. A direct agreement on tender prices is only one possible scenario. Unlawful coordination may also concern the decision not to submit a bid, the preparation of deliberately unattractive offers or the allocation of particular contracts between competitors.
Common forms of bid rigging include:
- agreeing which participant will submit the winning bid;
- submitting cover bids that are intentionally more expensive or less favourable than the selected bidder’s offer;
- agreeing that certain companies will refrain from bidding in a particular procedure;
- rotating winners in successive tenders;
- dividing contracts, territories, customers or categories of goods between competitors;
- exchanging commercially sensitive information before bids are submitted, including planned prices, margins, costs or bid conditions;
- using subcontracting arrangements to conceal coordination between nominally competing bidders.
Not every similarity between offers proves an unlawful agreement. Businesses operating in the same market may face comparable costs, supply conditions or technical requirements. However, repeated patterns, unusual pricing, identical errors in documents, coordinated withdrawals of bids or contacts between competitors may raise concerns and justify an internal review or an investigation by the relevant authorities.
When should a lawyer be consulted?
Legal assistance may be important before, during or after a procurement procedure. Businesses should seek advice when they intend to cooperate with other market participants, form a consortium, use subcontractors, exchange information with competitors or participate in a tender in which related entities are also bidding.
A lawyer can also assist where a company identifies circumstances suggesting that employees, managers, agents or commercial partners may have coordinated tender activity. Early legal analysis may help preserve relevant evidence, determine the scope of an internal investigation and assess obligations towards contracting authorities or competition authorities.
Support may also be required when a business is suspected of bid rigging, receives a request for information, is subject to an inspection or search, has been excluded from a procurement procedure, or faces potential civil, administrative or criminal consequences. The position of a company and that of an individual employee or board member may require separate assessment.
A prompt consultation can reduce the risk of procedural errors, inconsistent explanations, destruction of evidence, incorrect communication with authorities or decisions that increase financial and legal exposure. It may also help a business implement effective compliance measures for future tenders.
Legal support in bid rigging matters may include:
- assessing whether planned cooperation between bidders complies with competition and procurement rules;
- reviewing tender documentation, communications and commercial arrangements;
- conducting internal investigations concerning suspected anti-competitive conduct;
- advising management boards, employees and compliance officers;
- representing businesses and individuals in proceedings before authorities and courts;
- preparing responses to requests for information and other procedural correspondence;
- developing competition law compliance procedures for procurement activities.
Need legal assistance regarding suspected bid rigging or a tender-related investigation? Contact us.