What is the age of criminal responsibility?
The age of criminal responsibility is the minimum age at which a person may be held responsible for a criminal offence under criminal law. It determines whether an individual can be prosecuted and sentenced under the rules applicable to adults or whether the case should be dealt with under legislation concerning juveniles.
In Poland, the general age of criminal responsibility is 17. A person who commits a prohibited act after reaching this age is, as a rule, subject to the provisions of the Polish Criminal Code. This does not mean that age is irrelevant after the age of 17. The court may still take the offender’s level of maturity, personal circumstances and prospects for rehabilitation into account when determining the legal consequences of an offence.
The applicable rules are set out primarily in Article 10 of the Polish Criminal Code and in the Act on the Support and Resocialisation of Juveniles. The age of the person at the time of the alleged act is important. A person who was below the statutory threshold when the act was committed cannot generally be treated as an adult offender solely because they reached adulthood later.
How does the age of criminal responsibility work in Poland?
As a general rule, persons who commit a punishable act after reaching the age of 13 but before reaching the age of 17 are dealt with as juveniles. In proceedings involving juveniles, the primary focus is not punishment in the adult criminal-law sense but education, rehabilitation and prevention of further harmful behaviour. Depending on the circumstances, a family court may apply educational, therapeutic or corrective measures.
Polish law provides limited exceptions to the general threshold of 17. Under Article 10(2) of the Criminal Code, a person who has reached the age of 15 may, in exceptional circumstances, be held criminally liable under the Criminal Code for certain particularly serious offences. These include, among others, specified forms of homicide, serious bodily harm, conduct creating a public danger, unlawful seizure of a vessel or aircraft, aggravated rape, aggravated assault on a public official, hostage-taking and robbery. This possibility is not automatic. The court must assess the circumstances of the case, the offender’s level of development, personal characteristics and living conditions, particularly where previously applied juvenile measures have proved ineffective.
There is also a narrower exception concerning homicide. A person who has reached the age of 14 may be held criminally liable for qualified forms of homicide under Article 148(2) or Article 148(3) of the Criminal Code if the circumstances of the case and the offender’s development, characteristics and personal situation justify this approach, and if juvenile measures would not be capable of ensuring rehabilitation. This exception follows from Article 10(2a) of the Criminal Code.
Where a person aged 14 or 15 is tried under the Criminal Code pursuant to Article 10(2) or Article 10(2a), the penalty cannot exceed two-thirds of the statutory maximum penalty for that offence. In addition, a life sentence cannot be imposed on a person who was under 18 when the offence was committed. These rules are provided for in Article 10(3) and Article 54(2) of the Criminal Code.
When is legal assistance regarding criminal responsibility of a minor needed?
Legal assistance may be important as soon as a minor is questioned by the police, detained, suspected of an offence or summoned before a family court. The legal classification of the alleged act, the age of the minor and the procedural stage of the case may significantly affect which court has jurisdiction and which measures may be applied.
Support may also be needed by parents or legal guardians. They may need to understand the nature of juvenile proceedings, their rights and obligations, the possible consequences of a court decision and the practical impact of educational or corrective measures on the minor’s education, family life or future travel plans.
A prompt consultation with a criminal lawyer can help identify procedural irregularities, protect the minor’s rights during questioning, assess whether adult criminal liability is legally possible and prepare an appropriate response to allegations. Early legal advice may also reduce the risk of statements or decisions that could adversely affect the minor’s position in later proceedings.
Legal support in cases involving minors may include:
- assessing whether the case falls under juvenile law or the Criminal Code;
- representing a minor before a family court or criminal court;
- assistance during police questioning and detention-related procedures;
- analysing allegations and available evidence;
- preparing submissions, appeals and applications for modification of measures;
- advising parents and legal guardians on the course and consequences of proceedings;
- support in cases involving serious offences and possible criminal liability of a person aged 14 or 15.
Need legal assistance in a case involving the age of criminal responsibility? Contact us.